POLL: Absolute worst mascara you've ever tried (past or present) - BAR NONE

 


message by Stephie
more messages

expand whole threadPOLL: Absolute worst mascara you've ever tried (past or present) - BAR NONEStephie1/12/2013 5:23PM

Mac Zoom and UD Cannonball. And of course, Great Lash!kristalov1/21/2013 6:30PM

Just posted the best now I have the worst IMO.....frecklesrock1/21/2013 12:00PM

Great lash and Kiss Me mascara by Blinc. lilmissdani1/21/2013 11:17AM

Mac Zoom Mascara and Napoleon Perdisbrandi96891/21/2013 11:03AM

Loreal Voluminous zeecloud1/21/2013 6:51AM

mikaoya1/20/2013 10:20PM

Tarte Multipleye in 500-point perk. Didn't even stick to eyelashes, totally dried out when brand newSimplePleasures1/20/2013 4:24PM

Maybelline Great Lash - 50th (yes, I counted)Moremi1/20/2013 1:53PM

Great lash, Full n soft, diorshow - three failskiune1/20/2013 11:34AM

ELF mascara duo. Opened the tube to a dried product, but hey, you get what you pay for.NatanYah1/19/2013 10:03PM

With no hesitation.... Maybelline Great Lash pink/green tube. Horrible stuff!perfumejunky1/19/2013 3:59PM

Rimmel (all of them), Clinique high impact, Maybelline great,lash and lash stylist..horrible!!misscynthia061/19/2013 3:03PM

Almay "Get up and Grow" which I bought after watching Emily Noel (whose opinion I often agree with) 3110hello1/19/2013 12:35PM

The Revlon Grow Luscious I've used for the past month is the worst. Like worse than ELF wp. ROPEIGNA1/19/2013 11:06AM

perfumista11/19/2013 8:57AM

UD Big Fatty, EL Sumptous, Diorshow. And no more Maybelline!Nuppu1/19/2013 2:16AM

Maybelline the FalsiesGrandPriestess1/19/2013 1:33AM

Great Lash & that Clinique one w/the comb, not a brushdogdaze1/18/2013 7:28PM

My worst mascara is a toss up between masterpiece by Max Factor and Great Lash by Maybelline.sealegg1/18/2013 12:43PM

Revlon don't remember the name silver tube w/small brush which was clumped with formula not usable schliexo1/18/2013 11:56AM

Dior Show, absolute fail for mepoppemie1/18/2013 6:11AM

Agree. All hype No substance.XpugsX1/19/2013 3:13PM

The one in the neon green and pink tubetokiomama1/18/2013 3:49AM

Haha this is Great Lashsealegg1/18/2013 12:44PM

Great Lash and Hard Candy Lash Inkyoungpunkk1/18/2013 2:18AM

Great Lashlanih20031/18/2013 1:40AM

Stiletto, the red and black tube - too watery!hecatemacbeth1/18/2013 12:50AM

WORST MASCARA EVERWENDYROB1/18/2013 12:28AM

Agree-ALL Avon mascaras seen to be awfulKingTaco1/18/2013 5:54PM

Worst ever mascara is Maybelline Great Lashsarahdance1/17/2013 10:38PM

L'oreal telescopic something from a few years back. Nothing but crazy clumps!enamacheylove1/17/2013 5:34PM

Maybelline Great Lash and Benefit Bad Galcloroxcowgirl1/17/2013 3:21PM

Ugh- this!feelingcold1/20/2013 12:43PM

3rd. Both smear around your eyes throughout the day.fergiefergie1/21/2013 8:01AM

L'oreal Voluminous. Clumped like crazy. Combing lashes after did not help at all.DarkHairedBarbieDoll1/17/2013 2:53PM

All thr L'oreals I've tried have been horribly flaky!!!PerfumeShoesPolishBaby1/17/2013 1:19PM

agreekburditt1/17/2013 6:00PM

Great lash, full n soft, falsies ...just realized they're all Maybelline hahahajacqc1/17/2013 5:24AM

Napoleon. Australian brand that is waaay overrated in everyway but esp the mascara.meta181/17/2013 5:04AM

Maybelline Colossalxdevochkax1/17/2013 3:35AM

2nd...the smell gagged mefinn471/17/2013 5:20PM

hard candy..can't remember which one though. arkindt1/17/2013 1:25AM

Definitely Loreal feather lash. What a piece of crap.miniandboss1/16/2013 11:38PM

Some random new Maybelline mascara - I find that they are all pretty horrid and isn't it interesting3110hello1/16/2013 10:03PM

Bad gal lash, great lash, mega plushthefallofnadia1/16/2013 9:38PM

Maybelline great lash and benefit they're realbailokaye1/16/2013 9:03PM

Maybelline Great Lash. Runny, flaky, awful.maggiegault1/16/2013 7:10PM

Prestige My Blackest (Biggest) Lashes? & Loreal Voluminous.FrozenLips1/16/2013 4:00PM

Rimmel Volume Flash The Max Bold Curves--long *ss name for craptimothybcat1/16/2013 2:41PM

Khroma WP burned my eyeballs all day...even after I removed it. Love their eyeshadow, though! trisheee1/16/2013 1:25PM

Revlon- ColorStay & FabuLash. I have no luck with Revlon. katras1/16/2013 11:36AM

turbo lash was pretty ****justinetindall1/16/2013 10:59AM

Maybelline Great Lash.MalibuMands1/16/2013 10:06AM

Great lash by far.swtlilqtk1/15/2013 11:19PM

Tie between Maybelline define a lash and all avon mascaras I have ever tried.GuysCallMeShawna1/15/2013 9:21PM

Maybelline Great Lash and Mega Plushdakota20101/15/2013 9:14PM

Smashbox Bionic (flakes), Regular CG LB (clumpy), TF Lash Injection (smells)HeatherLouWho1/15/2013 2:06PM

Maybelline Great Last (pink tube). Atrocious garbage.lepin1/15/2013 2:01PM

hands down maybelline great lash. ugh.worrdworrdd1/15/2013 12:48AM

This doe_eyed_kitty1/15/2013 1:29AM

CG Lash Blastpetagirl1/14/2013 11:42PM

L'Oreal Voluminous (melted down my face), Great Lash, & Falsiestehnybor1/14/2013 7:39PM

YSL Volume Effet Faux Cils Shocking - Nothing but clumps and flakes!greenfaerie381/14/2013 6:37PM

L'Oreal Telescopic Explosionfustyluggz1/14/2013 4:59PM

Maybelline Great Lash original formulaLadyClaudia1/14/2013 4:50PM

2ndmbrow2221/14/2013 5:07PM

3rd.ilovemac031/15/2013 12:42AM

4thcamilla81/17/2013 12:31PM

5th... barbarella101/18/2013 7:56PM

5th... easy to apply and it actually does improve lashes.barbarella101/18/2013 7:55PM

Dior show Black Out. For that much $$ it shouldnt smudge everywherekeia11131/14/2013 12:31PM

dysfunctionxdoll1/14/2013 11:34AM

Maybelline Lash Stylist--dc'd now. Horrible stuff!BethyC1231/14/2013 10:35AM

almost forgot about this...horrid!! brush was so dumbmisscynthia061/19/2013 9:10AM

L'oréal Voluminous in Carbon Black waterproof. Smudged on me like crazy!BonjourMaria1/14/2013 10:27AM

2nd!aznmnkygrl8081/14/2013 5:57PM

All Merle Norman mascaras!kamiller19721/14/2013 9:32AM

MUFE Smokey lash waterproof. mst3knut1/14/2013 8:49AM

2nd! A lot if my lashes came out when I used a qtip & MU remover :{ohcaitlin1/14/2013 7:33PM

A tie between CG Lash Blast and Maybelline Great Lashnocturnefata1/14/2013 7:33AM

Thisscarlett07221/15/2013 5:00AM

2nd glm so much hype for no effectJBAngel11/14/2013 1:51PM

THIS! Omg, they are the WORSE!dysfunctionxdoll1/14/2013 11:47AM

Some Almay Naturals one in a white tube with flowers on it ;/bloodflower41411/14/2013 1:01AM

Also, Wet 'n' Wild - Mega Plump Mascara. DRY. It was cheap. Shoulda known better. brio8151/13/2013 11:24PM

Maybelline XXL and NYC Curling blue mascara. horrible brushes!fihe1/13/2013 11:22PM

Urban Decay Big Fatty, the blue one. FAILURE.missmanic1/13/2013 11:21PM

Maybelline Great Lash. maybe I bought the wrong one. It was a thin brush. Bleh. Hated it. brio8151/13/2013 11:16PM

Maybelline Great Lash and MAC Zoom Lash tie for hottest messhusserl1/13/2013 9:50PM

Revlon DoubleTwistblueroses25251/13/2013 9:21PM

thismadeline1011/14/2013 7:18PM

clinique high definition lashes. the comb brush is awesome though, I kept it as a brow groomer.jskellis1/13/2013 8:56PM

Revlon Fabulash. *shudders*skort1/13/2013 5:11PM

Benefit - BadGal melissa19861/13/2013 5:01PM

2nd!!ziya1/16/2013 1:02AM

This!marmaladecat1/15/2013 8:59AM

Yep, benefit mascaras are the driest flakiest garbage ever.Ashley925041/13/2013 5:39PM

Maybelline Great Lash-original formula+++katy241/13/2013 4:34PM

2nd, black water.madaket1/13/2013 7:22PM

Rimmel Scandaleyes Showoff - lashes broke off!cristy_amk1/13/2013 4:21PM

Max Factor false lash effect 24 waterproof. Clumpy mess that was a p.i.t.a to get off.donnz1/13/2013 3:49PM

Great lash... or heroine make :/ lots of eyelashes lost trying to get it off, even with an oily +rainbowrivulets1/13/2013 3:26PM

pretty much all of the maybelline brand. and ulta...their brand of mascara. lash blastLluviaCatMagic1/13/2013 2:01PM

Revlon Double Twistnicolegryne1/13/2013 2:01PM

Maybelline Great Lash, total trash.angelheartschanel20091/13/2013 1:19PM

secondnarkiz1/13/2013 3:15PM

Maybelline great lashchinadoll131/13/2013 1:16PM

CG Lash Blastkristel01061/13/2013 1:15PM

This- Big, stupid brush got mascara all over my eyelids- Threw it out!khvalles1/13/2013 3:56PM

Hard Candy Ginormous Lashraqqstarr1/13/2013 1:11PM

Worst MascaraJerseylicious051/13/2013 12:03PM

Revlon Grow Luscious. Horrible.CPSWarrior1/13/2013 11:48AM

this, crap in a tubeHanouna1/18/2013 11:23PM

4th! Do not understand the hype!!karissajean1/14/2013 7:25PM

Haha, this was awfullechickpea1/14/2013 10:38AM

The brush is huge! So unnecessary. brio8151/13/2013 11:17PM

this! irimoto1/13/2013 6:19PM

3rd...worst everlazylittlelady1/13/2013 10:15PM

Revlon Double Twist. Hey Revlon, YOU try to take a clump of tar & put it on your lashes!!drugstorediva31/13/2013 11:05AM

Wretched, wretched stuff!pln3151/20/2013 11:07PM

That's the one I was trying to remember the name of. shazzer19761/13/2013 11:33AM

2nd!kirat1/13/2013 11:26AM

3rd what were they thinking when they made that?xVegasx1/15/2013 3:21PM

I thought I'd got a dud tube 'til I came here : /slaybelle1/20/2013 7:02AM

That revlon one with the awful brush! Put me off Revlon mascaras for ever.shazzer19761/13/2013 10:41AM

Victoria Jackson -- total racoon eyes!historian121/13/2013 9:50AM

Maybelline define-a-lash (pulled out lashes plus I'm allergic to formula LE SUCK!bergamott1/13/2013 2:06AM

Majolica Majorca Lash Expander Frame Plus. (gets so many raves on Pville, blech)NoirAngelx1/12/2013 6:16PM

Tie between the djv Fiberwig and Benefit's They're RealJulie3561/12/2013 5:43PM

agree on the benefit they're real!alexa191/12/2013 5:54PM

yes- benefit's They're Real is awful! calimoonchild1/19/2013 1:29AM

Voluminous. For real.snoopie31/12/2013 5:42PM

4thkburditt1/15/2013 8:26PM

2nd - Instant panda eyes!RedHedd1/12/2013 6:28PM

3rd hate it!blooiejagwa1/13/2013 6:43PM

benefit bad galalexa191/12/2013 5:38PM

So clumpy and goopy on the brush- finally got rid of it after struggling with it.khvalles1/13/2013 3:57PM

MAC Zoom Lash maybe.spookydeuce1/12/2013 5:37PM

It refused to work for me too :(ohcaitlin1/14/2013 7:35PM

All lancomerupertlilly8 1/12/2013 5:37PM

Bourjois Coup de Theatre. Horrific.Risa011/12/2013 5:36PM

I actually liked that one. Funny how we are all so different, esp. with mascara IMOdrugstorediva31/13/2013 11:06AM

Benefit bad gal. Raccoon eyes almost immediatelyjingyo1/12/2013 5:36PM

2ndclairerenee1/19/2013 8:03PM

YSL Something Shocking. The shock is that you look like you have 2black eyes @ end of eveningtightsweatergirl1/12/2013 5:35PM

It''s a toss-up between Edward Bess and BurberryKoren1/12/2013 5:33PM

Armani eyes to kill. Raccoon city for me at that price :/gingitsune1/12/2013 5:31PM

bekaboo1/15/2013 8:20PM

The Waterproof ETK is my HGKoren1/12/2013 5:38PM

Revlon, forgot the exact name.marie281/12/2013 5:30PM

MAC Zoom blah blah blah HATED it!HeavensDevil1/12/2013 5:29PM

L'oreal Telescopic death ball thing & Maybelline Falsies/Colossal were all awful imeFreddieR1/12/2013 5:29PM

Uuh the death ball -,- fmlohcaitlin1/14/2013 7:34PM

Chanel inimitable wp.Valerie11/12/2013 5:28PM

clump crusher. roxina1/12/2013 5:27PM

Why??? I just bought this!mica1/12/2013 5:43PM

it was way too natural looking on me, could hardly tell I was wearing any :/roxina1/12/2013 5:47PM

Aw I love Clump Crusher. Sorry it didn't work for youCPSWarrior1/13/2013 11:49AM

Ive had good and bad from same brand/mascara. Sometimes I've. had a bad dried out batch if that makeblush121/12/2013 5:25PM

N.Y.C in the pink tubeplanetnars1/12/2013 5:25PM

Maybelline great lash. foodielove1/12/2013 5:23PM

50thsicksexfix1/20/2013 11:47AM

Agree. Great lash is not great (its horrible).ishadow20001/18/2013 7:16PM

OMG yes, wet gloopy and left me looking like i have 5 lashesAishteru851/17/2013 8:14AM

This or WnW Mega plumped or something close to thatshgirl21/14/2013 3:45PM

Definitely the worst.hopflower1/14/2013 12:21PM

Yep.maxxine1/14/2013 6:24AM

This.angelbones1/13/2013 11:46PM

OK, it's not the worst I've ever tried but it's hardly worthy of all the awards it wins. Blah. drugstorediva31/13/2013 11:08AM

Yes. Terrible. I don't understand why people love it.lirpalynn1/13/2013 10:40AM

Agree - wet goopy mess on me :(kathyjanet1/12/2013 7:33PM

This!cyborgannie1/12/2013 6:25PM

this. hated it!geana281/12/2013 5:45PM

thisMissOleiane1/12/2013 5:30PM

2ndrmulieri1/12/2013 5:24PM

3rd. Could never understand all the fuss8ball1/12/2013 5:26PM

3rddogdaze1/12/2013 5:26PM

7thscotophobic1/12/2013 6:12PM

8thRedHedd1/12/2013 6:29PM

100000thfacesbyj1/14/2013 10:24PM

10thkamiller19721/14/2013 9:33AM

9thmartiantraveler1/12/2013 6:49PM