10 Best Eye Shadows for Normal skin

Pin It

Based on 24298 reviews of 6706 eye shadows from 290 brands, written by MakeupAlley users with normal skin, these are the 10 best eye shadows for normal skin

MAC Matte2 - Blanc Type

4.7

227 reviews

89% would repurchase

BEST REVIEWexpand

Another wonderful Matte2 eyeshadow...this is a superpigmented bone shade that destroys my BB Bone in texture and color...it actually shows up - what a revelation! I

MORE >>
Milani Java Bean (18)

4.7

182 reviews

92% would repurchase

BEST REVIEWexpand

PICTURES AND SWATCHES INCLUDED. Please click Continued for full review.
Price: 1, Packaging: 4, Rebuy: Yes
This is my HG brown e/s because it's ridiculou

MORE >>
MAC Frost - Phloof! (Hollidazzle)

4.6

265 reviews

89% would repurchase

BEST REVIEWexpand

Alright mature, middle aged ladies, listen up! If used by itself on its own, Phloof is a frosty, wrinkle-accentuating, crepey-eyelid nightmare. BUT, if used appropri

MORE >>
Wet 'n' Wild Color Icon Single - Brulee

4.6

415 reviews

91% would repurchase

BEST REVIEWexpand

Another "Hells yes I would buy again" item. It evens out redness, purpleness, blueness, and "Man, I slept like CRAP!"-ness on my upper eyelid. And under my lower

MORE >>
MAC Frost - Bronze

4.6

263 reviews

87% would repurchase

BEST REVIEWexpand

You know those commercials. The ones with a sexy model wearing a sexy smile looking all sexy with her sexy smokey bronze eye. Well, this eyeshadow is about as close

MORE >>
MAC Frost - Sable

4.6

258 reviews

86% would repurchase

BEST REVIEWexpand

I love Sable. The shade is a very wearable medium-darkish, plum brown with a tinge of golden bronze shimmer frost. It definitely has more shimmer than Romp, Mulch or

MORE >>
MAC Pigment in Violet

4.6

213 reviews

89% would repurchase

BEST REVIEWexpand

i'll be the first to admit it - i have a serious purple "affliction". i have SOOO many...But it is hard to find what i call neutral purples for my skin tone (ones th

MORE >>
Milani Antique Gold #17

4.5

178 reviews

92% would repurchase

BEST REVIEWexpand

Very pretty olivey gold (more olive than anything else) with fine gold shimmers. I've tried Sumptuous Olive and found that I preferred Antique Gold since Sumptuous O

MORE >>
MAC Satin - Cork

4.5

202 reviews

90% would repurchase

BEST REVIEWexpand

I uploaded a photo and linked it and the bottom of this review. I was using UD Buck in my crease and I read endless reviews noting that it's a dupe for MAC Cork. Saw

MORE >>
MAC Satin - Smut

4.5

139 reviews

87% would repurchase

BEST REVIEWexpand

My favourite eyeshadow formula/colour EVER! Whoever said its a staple for any makeup-bag, you are spot-on. I have found this product to be great for smokey heavy

MORE >>

Popular Eye Shadows

SEE MORE >>

Follow Us

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google
  • Pinterest

Back to Top